Benzene, a potent carcinogen found in many Sodas
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: May 19, 2006
CONTACT: EWG Public Affairs Staff, (202) 667-6982
FDA Finds High Benzene Levels in Limited Test of Drinks
Today FDA announced it found high levels of benzene in several samples in a test of a small number of sodas and juice drinks.
"FDA's test results confirm that there is a serious problem with benzene in soda and juices," said Richard Wiles, senior vice president at Environmental Working Group.
In a very limited sample of products, FDA found two popular drinks—Safeway Diet Orange and Crystal Light Sunrise Classic Orange—with up to 17 times more benzene than allowed in tap water, and three other products with benzene levels up to four times the drinking water limit. Many other products had detectable levels of the carcinogen.
"There is no excuse for deliberately putting chemicals that form high levels of potent cancer-causing benzene in popular drinks," Wiles said. "This is a wake-up call for the beverage industry. It is time to get benzene-forming ingredients out of sodas and juices."
FDA Found the Potent Carcinogen Benzene in 10 Soft Drinks at Levels Up to 17 Times The EPA Drinking Water Standard
Crystal Light Sunrise Classic Orange (lot 1)87.9-76.6 ppb
Safeway Select Diet Orange (lot 1)79.2 ppb
Crystal Light Sunrise Classic Orange (lot 3)73.9 ppb
AquaCal Strawberry Flavored Water Beverage (lot 1)23.4 ppb
Safeway Select Diet Orange (lot 2)15.2-10.7 ppb
Safeway Select Diet Orange (lot 3)13.2-11.4 ppb
Giant Light Cranberry Juice Cocktail (lot 1)10.7-9.1 ppb
AquaCal Strawberry Flavored Water Beverage (lot 2)10.4-9.2 ppb
Crush Pineapple9.2 ppb
Giant Light Cranberry Juice Cocktail (lot 2)5.4 ppb
Note: EPA drinking water standard for benzene is 5 parts per billion (ppb)
Source: FDA Data on Benzene in Soft Drinks
http://www.ewg.org/images/bulletin/bulletin_header.gif Dear Friend,
I wanted to share with you an important food safety update that the Environmental Working Group (EWG) and our online community helped bring about.
Last Friday, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) released the names of five beverages that it found had high levels of cancer-causing benzene. Two brands -- Safeway Diet Orange soda and Crystal Light Sunrise Classic Orange -- had 17 times the level of benzene that is allowed in tap water. As a result of EWG's pressure and publicity, the FDA committed to testing more products, and several major manufacturers, including Kraft and Schweppes, agreed to reformulate their beverages.
To see a list of the most-contaminated beverages, and EWG's media statement, click here.
EWG first sounded the warning in late February that consumers should scan their soda labels for the presence of both sodium benzoate and ascorbic acid, two chemicals that combine to form benzene, a potent carcinogen. We did so after uncovering evidence that the FDA's own tests, going back as far as 1995, had found disturbing levels of benzene in soft drinks.
In spite of our efforts, the FDA continued to proclaim that consumers had nothing to worry about. Only after an EWG petition drive and public awareness campaign did the agency back down and agree to release testing information on some beverages.
But they didn't go far enough. These test results, which cover only a small fraction of the beverages on the market today, show that there's a serious problem with benzene in soda and juices. The very least FDA can do is disclose test results for all soft drinks containing benzene-forming chemicals.
There should be a zero tolerance policy for benzene in any consumer product. There's simply no excuse for this potent carcinogen to be in any drink.
This drama has been playing out since 1990, when the FDA first learned of the benzene problem and, rather than informing the public about it, decided to allow the beverage industry to address it on its own. The industry, by all accounts, did nothing. But the FDA kept the lid on information that could have helped consumers avoid benzene-laden drinks.
A government agency siding with industry and against the health of our children -- that's the kind of behavior that motivates us to action. At EWG, we believe in the power of information to protect people's health, and we'll continue to fight for your right to know about dangerous chemicals in the products you buy.
Thanks for being part of our community,
Ken
President
I Wann Kill This BITCH!!!
SAN FRANCISCO
Family's tragic story told on police video
Oakland woman details drowning 3 sons, tape shows
John Koopman, Chronicle Staff Writer
Thursday, May 25, 2006
http://www.sfgate.com/c/pictures/200..._0042afl_t.gif
Lashuan Harris' children did not go quietly to their deaths.
Trayshaun, the oldest at 6, was the first to go over the railing at San Francisco's Pier 7. He fought her as she took off his clothes, his mother told police afterward. He said, "No, Mama. What are you doing?"
The second child, 2-year-old Taronta, struggled, too, as she wrestled him out of his clothes, and then screamed as he went over the side.
The little one, 16-month-old Joshua, had gotten out of his stroller and was playing around, she said. Harris said she took off Joshua's clothing, too. He clung to her tightly, she said, before she tossed him into the water.
Those heartbreaking stories came from a videotaped interview conducted by San Francisco homicide investigators the evening of Oct. 19, hours after the Oakland woman allegedly killed her three children. The interview was shown Wednesday in court, where San Francisco Superior Court Judge Teri Jackson is conducting a preliminary hearing to determine whether Harris should stand trial.
She is charged with three counts of murder and three counts of child abuse.
Harris' attorney, Assistant Public Defender Teresa Caffese, said her client is mentally ill, that she committed the acts because she heard voices in her head. She believed, Caffese said, that God was telling her to kill her children.
The hearing began Tuesday. Later that day and most of Wednesday morning, the court watched the videotape of the detectives questioning Harris the night the children died.
Harris sat impassively at the defense table. Family and friends who came to court cried quietly as they listened to her describe in the taped interview how she killed her children.
"He didn't know what I was doing," Harris said of Trayshaun.
"Did he try to get away?" a homicide inspector asked.
"Yes," she said.
"Then what did you do?"
"I picked him up.''
The detectives continued to ask questions about Trayshaun, but Harris had a hard time answering. She seemed detached in the video, almost comatose. The officers had to repeat questions several times, and her answers were brief: "yes," "no" or "I don't know."
Taronta, Harris said, knew what she was doing after having watched Trayshaun go into the water.
"What was he saying?" a homicide detective asked Harris.
"Mama," she replied.
Taronta was the only child whose body was recovered. The others are still missing.
Inspectors Daniel Everson and Dennis Maffei treated Harris gently during the interview, never raising their voices but persistent in their questions. Harris showed little emotion during most of the interview, but later, after the officers had left the room with the camera running, she burst into tears and wailed uncontrollably.
As Harris talked about dropping her children into the bay, they asked her several times if she knew right from wrong, and whether it was wrong to do what she did.
"When Taronta was fighting you, did that make you think what you were doing was wrong?" one asked.
"Yeah," Harris responded.
But more often, she referred to "the voices." One of the inspectors asked if she was hearing voices right then, during the interview. "A little bit," she said. When asked to describe the voices, she could not. The voices told her to make "a living sacrifice" to God, she said.
Earlier Wednesday, a psychiatrist testified that Harris suffers from paranoid schizophrenia and thought that heaven was an actual place where she could send her sons.
Dr. Gil Villela, an attending psychiatrist at San Francisco General Hospital, said he met with 24-year-old Harris the day after the incident on Pier 7.
He said Harris was cooperative, very sedate and open to answering questions during the session. He said she suffered from "command auditory hallucinations," that is, voices telling her what to do. His immediate diagnosis was that she suffered from psychosis. Over time, he said, he came to the determination that she was a paranoid schizophrenic.
"She had a delusional thought disorder of a religious nature," he testified. "She had been told by God to put her children into the bay."
During the time he saw Harris, she gave him a letter she had written to her children and asked him to put it on an airplane to be taken to heaven, he said. The outside of the envelope was addressed, in crayon, "To Heaven."
"Dear God," the letter began. "I did what you told me. Now I'm in lock up and in a crazy house." In words written to her children, Harris had written, "I just wanted to tell you I love you. How is heaven holding up? Kiss my boys for me."
E-mail John Koopman at [email protected].