jackie chan > jet li > Donnie Yen

[M.O.D.]

ya dudes still goin off on jackie chan & jet li , give it a rest yall & let the votes decide

[100pr00f]

"Shanghai 1
Shanghai 2
the young tiger
fire dragon.........................................tra sh...worst kung flick i own
fantasy mission force............................trash...2nd worst kung fu movie i own
eagle shadow fist....................................trash
master with the cracked fingers
winners and sinners...........................1
my lucky stars....................................2
their is a 3rd...no copies are being sold anywhere
the myth...........got some ok ratings..but effects are wack as hell in this flick

spiritual kung fu
the suit
twin dragons
cannon ball run
cannon ball run 2
the protector
new fist of fury
36 crazy fist
angry ranger
fearless hyena 2
fist of anger....said to be worst ever made...afraid to look
the medallion
rumble in hong kong
to kill with intrigue
half of loaf of kung fu
island of fire
rush hour 1
rush hour 2
rush hour 3"

here u go

man thats a loooong list of bad films.......lol

jackie is king...king at making the most failed films


name some one who has more bad films then jackie.......lol


no one

[100pr00f]

most of thos films...are 70's 80's


their u go...........

[DrunkenMasta303]

ya dudes still goin off on jackie chan & jet li , give it a rest yall & let the votes decide

^^ppl are discussing films n shit, thats what InTerNET FoRUmS are about...

As predicted, you have to block out the last 10+ years to appreciate Jackie Chan, whereas you don't need to do that in order to appreciate Jet Li.
Chan is almost 10 years older than Li, jet li is 46 now, when chan was in his 40ies he was dropping Bangers like ''First Strike''(and many more)

You're right, Chan is doing what Jet is NOT doing, which is making consistently bad films for awhile. BTW, Fearless (especially the director's cut) Jet Li had quite the hand in and that's a recent film. You won't find ANY bad reviews of that either.i dont see the point ur trying to make by bringin up that 1 movie each time

You're grasping onto small details that can easily be argued against because they're flawed.

Li & Chan use wires (then and now)
Li & Chan have films were they didn't use wires (then & now)
the relation is about 80% to 7%
If you're going for the numbers game ("BUT LI USES WIRES MORE THAN CHAN, SO THAT MAKES CHAN BETTER!!!!")
then you have to accept that Chan has far more wack films than Li does too. thats your opinionIf you don't agree, then break down those films that 100proof was nice enough to list and defend their wackness since you're a fan of Chan. Should be amusing to say the least.like i said b4, those are some commercial Hollywood films made by a veeery old man, theres no reason for me to give those films a serious judgement. But i will say this tho (about their old stuff): the WACK jackie chan films are wacker than the wack jet li films, but the DOPE jackie chan films are EASILY doper than the dope jet li films, IMO

Being able to pose and flip is not martial arts,capoeira for instance is DANCING and flipping and its STILL considered martial arts, just a different form of martial arts but if that impresses you more then so be it. But using that as a basis to claim superiority in martial arts films when one person is a martial artist, while the other is not, is laughable at best.ive never seen jackie chan in a REAL fight, same with jet li, so i can ONLY judge their skillz from watching their movies, and chan is showing waaay more skillz in his movies than li

But hey, there are those who think Godfather is long & boring, while Freddie Got Fingered is a fun enjoyable film. So opinions, ya know.LOL, true, btw Godfather is CLASSIC

[DrunkenMasta303]

2X PLAT!


keepin threadz ALIVE like a E-DOKTA!!

[hide1998]

ike i said b4, those are some commercial Hollywood films made by a veeery old man, theres no reason for me to give those films a serious judgement. But i will say this tho (about their old stuff): the WACK jackie chan films are wacker than the wack jet li films, but the DOPE jackie chan films are EASILY doper than the dope jet li films, IMO

Did you even read that list? Most of those are films from the 70s and 80s, not "some commercial Hollywood films made by a veeery old man." As you're proving, EVEN CHAN'S FANS can't defend them. So the point still stands. Stop ignoring the argument by repeating that "Hollywood films" line when that has nothing to do with what is being pointed out.

[The Hound]

Jet Li 8 47.06%
Jackie Chan 9 52.94%

[hide1998]

Jet Li 8 47.06%
Jackie Chan 9 52.94%

Kinda asinine to compare results that close this early, but in continuing with a point I guess you're trying to make, how about an update...

Jet Li 9 50.00%
Jackie Chan 9 50.00%

[The Hound]

LOL

The Jet Li stan strikes back.

[hide1998]

LOL

The Jet Li stan strikes back.

You do realize you JUST posted the poll results right? Or is calling me a stan a random part of your speech?

Finger-pointing in this regard is silly based on your track record in this thread.

[100pr00f]

haha this is true^^^ dude calls u a stan...but then posts the poll

lol

seems like he is 10 right

[RagnaroK]

What is this Jackie Chan ain't a real martial artist thing isn't Martial Arts one of the things students must train and learn on Peking Opera Schools?

[hide1998]

What is this Jackie Chan ain't a real martial artist thing isn't Martial Arts one of the things students must train and learn on Peking Opera Schools?

No, martial arts is not one of the things students must train and learn to be in Peking Opera Schools.

Do some of you really think that anyone who can back-flip knows martial arts?

Prof.RINO - Yes I know about Caporera. In fact, I use to study it (along with Kempo). What that has to do with Jackie Chan is beyond me, but I figured you had some point with it. What I was saying is that many people know how to pose and flip (like Jackie Chan), but that doesn't make them martial artists.

Some REALLY loose definitions of the term in here.

[100pr00f]

What is this Jackie Chan ain't a real martial artist thing isn't Martial Arts one of the things students must train and learn on Peking Opera Schools?

false....


mainly train in drama

for ...when they put on shows..for the public ....were do u think jackie learned to sing

ma was apart of the opera..only for the movie guys,,,like the venoms group were they learn a lil bit of ma..to help out with filming

chan never was making movies...untill the opera school was closed down

thats when chan, sammo..and yuen
came together and tryed out for movies


chan was in movies as a child..but they were dramas

like buce lee films
when he was a child


small note..chan did learn wushu when he was a child from his father..that was for obedience..he was a bad kid...but never learned or cared which is y they sent him to peaking opera school where they were strict and he couldt leave


every mistake he was hit by the trainer


sim......to jet li

but li was training in wushu plus other styles...

not dance

[oDoUoSoKo]

> Jet li & Jackie Chan