f*uck That Last Thread ....Beatles Vs Pink Floyd

[MaXiMus Da MaNtis]

Straight Two Of Rocks Forfronts No Comment From Me Imma Just Vote

[hansei]

Beatles are horrible.

[rainbow]

Pink Floyd by trillions of of light years.

[UNCLE RUCKUS]

Beatles, though I do like Pink Floyd I just dont think they have more than 3 classic albums (Wish You Were Here, The Wall and Darkside). The Beatles got Revolver, Sgt.Peppers, The White Album, Rubber Soul and Abbey Road

[The Hound]

Still The Beatles.

[JASPER]

Pink Floyd by trillions of of light years.

Agreed.

Never been much of a Beatles fan, or Stones fan.

I was listening to Atom Mother Heart in 4 channel on my quad the other night, stoned as an unfaithful Iraqi woman. Righteous.

[INF]

beatles catalog is thicker imo.

only floyd I really like is Waters floyd anyway.

[tajeco]

Beatles are horrible.

Good argument. I'm convinced now that I was wrong the whole time. May I ask, who is your favorite artist? Akon? Cheeta Girls?

[rainbow]

I've never really "got" the Beatles like a lot of people seem to, so my opinion doesn't really count for much.

I just feel as though, while their music is obviously extremely influential, it never blows my mind. In context i'm sure it was amazing, but as someone who only had the opportunity to listen to their music from the 90's onwards, it has mild impact upon me.

I prefer some Beatles solo shit to their album material, which is probably an indication of insanity to most Beatles fans...whatever though.

However, listening to Pink Floyd for the first time, or on any occasion thereafter has generally blown my mind.

You're hard pressed to find music that sounds like Pink Floyd, their music has a quality to it which is rarely emulated.

[JASPER]

You're hard pressed to find music that sounds like Pink Floyd, their music has a quality to it which is rarely emulated.

Although I agree Pink Floyd are one of the best in their category, there are a lot of bands (mostly unknown) that sound a lot like them, some copied their style, some were doing it before Pink Floyd existed. They're not completely unique, but the same goes for the Beatles.

I think it all boils down to whether you like poppy singy songs or long symphonic songs. I prefer the latter.

[rainbow]

You think so?

The only bands i've heard that capture a similar sound are heavily influenced by them.

I'm not saying there weren't bands previous that had that sound, i've just never heard them (i'm referring to Dark Side of the Moon/Wish You Were Here/Animals era Floyd in that respect, the earlier stuff is comparable to a lot of other musicians)

Put me onto some.

I'd say PF were definitely more original than the Beatles, but that's only my opinion i guess.

[Ghost In The 'Lac]

aint fucking with the beatles

[oDoUoSoKo]

hard ass question...so im not gonna answer.

[Memory Man]

beatles win.

[oDoUoSoKo]

this really shouldnt be an easy answer for anyone familiar with both of their catalogs.