Thanks to everybody who helped compile the list, you know who you are.
I ended up doing this like the NCAA selection committee, each song had a rating like an RPI, and from those songs on the bubble I went with the stronger album typically. Of course there are snubs so lets start with those...
Pit Bull Fights 8 47.06%
0% Finance
6 46.15%
4:21 Intro
18 43.90%
Be This Way
10 43.48%
Animal Planet
10 43.48%
Intro/Show You Love
15 42.86%
Destruction Of A Guard
13 41.94%
4:20
17 41.46%
Musketeers Of Pig Alley
7 41.18%
The W
16 41.03%
Build Strong
14 40.00%
Sickness
14 40.00%
Glocko Pop
14 40.00%
Shorty Right There
6 40.00%
Life Changes
18 40.00%
Whip You With A Strap
15 39.47%
Paisley Darts
11 39.29%
Knock, Knock
9 39.13%
Exploitation Of Mistakes
12 38.71%
Rules
15 38.46%
Fast Cars
13 38.24%
Killa Beez
8 38.10%
When you Walk(Box in Hand remix)
8 38.10%
Black Cream aka My Guitar
8 38.10%
Walking Through The Darkness
9 37.50%
Underwater
14 36.84%
AutoBio
8 36.36%
Whatever
13 35.14%
Secret Rivals
13 35.14%
Take It Back
15 34.88%
These won't be on the countdown, sorry maybe next year.
Here is the album breakdown, each album received representation from at least 1 song
9 OB4CL 2
8 8 Diagrams
7 No Said Date
6 Fishscale
6 Iron Flag
5 Pro Tools
5 Grandmasters
5 Birth of a Prince
5 More Fish
4 Dopium
4 4:21 the day after
4 Bulletproof Wallets
4 Made in Brooklyn
3 Digital Bullet
3 Tical 0
3 Legend of a Liquid Sword
3 Chamber Music
3 The Pretty Toney Album
3 The Movement
2 Digi Snacks
2 The Resident Patient
1 Wizard of poetry
1 The Big Doe Rehab
1 Mr. Xcitement
1 Lex Diamond Story
3 unreleased
and album popularity according to review thread (out of 41)
No Said Date (8)
Grandmasters (11)
8 Diagrams (15)
Pro Tools (16)
OB4CL2 (17)
Iron Flag (18)
Fishscale (19)
Legend of a Liquid Sword (21)
Birth of a Prince (22)
Chamber Music (23)
Digital Bullet (25)
Dopium (26)
Bulletproof Wallets (27)
4:21...The Day After (28)
The Pretty Toney Album (29)
The Movement (31)
Digi Snacks (32)
Made In Brooklyn (33)
More Fish (34)
Immobilarity (35)
The Big Doe Rehab (36)
The Resident Patient (37)
The Wizard of Poetry (38)
Lex Diamond Story (39)
Tical 0: The Prequel (40)
Mr. Xcitement (41)
Bookmarks